Skip to main content

How a highway contractor caught three weeks of extra work outside its BOQ and filed a variation for it

4 min read

A highway contractor in India spent about three weeks painting two toll plazas on its stretch, and the site team posted the work on WhatsApp as routine updates. Velora's month-end review found that the work matched no item in the BOQ, and turned up a letter from the client's engineer, posted in the same group, saying so. Velora pooled the site's updates and photos into a record by plaza and by date, and the contractor used it to submit a variation request to its client.

At a glance

  • Contractor: a highway contractor in India
  • The work: painting and signage at two toll plazas, over about three weeks
  • What Velora found: work that matched no BOQ item, and the engineer's letter confirming it fell outside the BOQ
  • The evidence: 45 site updates and 53 photos, each with its date and plaza
  • Result: a work record with photographs that backed the contractor's variation request for the extra work

The contractor​

The contractor works on a long stretch of highway under an item-rate contract, paid on measured quantities against its BOQ. Its site team reports the day's work in the project's WhatsApp group.

The situation​

The two toll plazas on the stretch were repainted: exterior walls and facade, interior walls and ceilings, doors and handrails, canopy columns, the steel framework of the booths, and lettering and signage. To the site team it was ordinary work. It went into the WhatsApp group the way everything else did, mostly as photos with no caption, or a line like "painting work in progress".

Work like this is easy to lose. The contractor has already paid for it, and by the time anyone claims it, the evidence is scattered through weeks of chat. Here, even the letter from the client's engineer about the work had arrived as a PDF in the same group, among hundreds of site photos.

What changed​

Velora read the site group's posts as they arrived and kept each one as a work record, with its photos and its date. Where a post had no caption, Velora described what the photo showed.

At month end, Velora's review checked the month's records against the BOQ, and the toll plaza painting matched no item. In the same group, the review found the engineer's letter: the toll plaza painting and signage appeared to fall outside the existing BOQ items, and the engineer asked for an item-wise statement of the work. With the letter confirming it, Velora flagged the work as extra work for the contractor's team to raise. For the first few months, the Velora team runs this review together with the contractor.

Velora then pooled the evidence into a work record for the two toll plazas:

  • a summary by plaza and by component (walls, ceilings, doors and handrails, columns, steel framework, signage), with the dates and the number of updates and photos for each
  • one line per site update: the date, the component, what the photo shows, and the site team's own words
  • the photographs in date order, each with its plaza, date and component

The record is also clear about its limits: the site updates gave no quantities, so it gives none rather than estimating them.

The result​

The contractor used the work record and photographs to submit a variation request to its client for the toll plaza work. Work the site had posted as routine painting, scattered across three weeks of WhatsApp photos, became a dated record of extra work for each plaza, with the engineer's own letter behind it.

Velora flagged the work and pooled the evidence. The contractor's team raised the request.

In their words​

"That [the toll plaza find] was absolutely correct. The system detected it right, and the photos helped us prepare the variation submission to the client for approval. It’s definitely outside BOQ extra work"

— GM Projects, highway contractor, India